For people who like and prefer the tucked or factory look, I'd really be interested in hearing your thought on this after you vote. :yup:
I prefer the factory/tucked look. Which is what I have right now. Eventually I'll be going with flat fenders though, because of the extra clearance they'll provide. I only have a 2.5" lift and will be running 35's. Right now I'm running large 33's (33.4"), and they occasionally scrape the fenders when I'm really flexing. If money was no object, I would keep my factory fenders, or get larger ones that would cover my larger tires and get a bigger lift to run 35's. And hell as long as money is no object, let me go ahead and upgrade axles, re-gear, and get 37's!! oh, but now I'm probably really gonna need flat fenders for those 37's.. sigh. LOL!
The reason I like the factory look is just a personal preference, I think the flat fenders look silly, like they are there for looks only and have no function. To me, the Fenders and the grill are two distinctive identifying features that are uniquely JEEP. If I ever traded out my grill, I would want the new grill to still have the 7 vertical slots, retaining something of a factory jeep look. I feel the same about the fenders.
Having said that, and since money IS an object, I'm still going to cut mine for extra clearance once I've got the larger tires...