The OEM for the 2018 Sahara was a Bridgestone Dueler HT which is basically a heavy duty highway tire with some All Season attributes. One of the biggest slams against them is they don't last very long.
By your description, you're wanting an All Terrain tire, but the caveat, no matter what you put on you're going to get noise. Even high end,
all season high performance tires make noise.
Your location doesn't give any help either, MidWest could mean anything from an AT to you're needing blizzard rated tires.
The more info you give, the better info you'll get.