I know I'm still pretty new to the forums and to offroading, but I have couple small inputs. I learned in my Dad's old manual CJ-5, so needless to say I stalled out a bunch of times when first started. And of course my Dad always saying, "Manual is the only way to enjoy off roading!" Although, with my recent purchase I went auto mainly because I had my wife in mind and I wanted her to enjoy driving the Jeep as well. With the recent trail I went on, even know it was pretty easy, the auto made it ever so much more easy. Yet, I should say it didn't kill the fun or enjoyment... Just like mentioned before, you don't have to worry about stalling and can pay more attention to everything around you. Either way, personal preference...pro's an con's to both transmissions...